Updated July 2026

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille (Sister Bay)

“A second, separate Wild Tomato. This one is tucked between Highway 42 and Sister Bay's public beach, with its own beach bar and garage bar. Same wood-fired pizza concept as the original Fish Creek restaurant, different water view, and open year-round rather than seasonally.”

The Sister Bay location of Wild Tomato's wood-fired pizza, a separate restaurant from the original Fish Creek location, between Highway 42 and the public beach.

Seasonal: No reservations; hours shift seasonally — call ahead outside summer.

Photos via Google